The intention of DISCIPLINE ANSWERS is to offer support to educators and parents who are interested in promoting responsibility and self-discipline in young people, through the use of Dr. Marvin Marshall’s DISCIPLINE without STRESS approach.

Kerry Weisner, a teacher of 30 years from British Columbia, Canada, shares her own enthusiasm, experiences and thoughts, as well as those of Dr. Marshall, and members of the DISCIPLINE without STRESS mailring, in an attempt to encourage others who see the value in motivating youth to act from a place of internal motivation. Most questions featured on this site were originally posed on the DISCIPLINE Without STRESS mailring at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Disciplinewithoutstress/

Kerry currently holds two part-time teaching positions, both of which she shares with a partner. She works as a grade one/two classroom teacher for half of each week and then moves to an alternate high school, working one-on-one in a literacy program with 16-19 year olds, who are either learning to read for the first time or who are interested in improving their current reading and writing skill levels.

Please feel free to respond, ask a question or share your own experiences using the comment box under each entry.


QUESTION:
I find that sometimes my high school students resent me asking them their level. At first I was giving them lots of essays and self-diagnostic referrals from the back of the book, but I understand that you don’t really recommend that either. Can you help me better understand how I should deal [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
We use DWS at our school–a high-poverty, high-needs school, with many angry, disruptive, disrespectful students. As the social worker, I really like the philosophy that DWS espouses, but I do notice one problem.
Students often see the “essay” as a punishment. It can become a power-struggle with some teachers. Do you have any [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
I once had a grade 8 student who said, “It doesn’t matter what level I say I’m on, you’re always going
to find a way to tell me that I’m on an unacceptable level.”
I’m wondering what a teacher might say in response to something like that?
RESPONSE FROM Tammy
Shared on the DISCIPLINE without STRESS Mailring:
I’d [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


Just like people, book characters often operate on more than one level!
Very often, the author has at least one character learn something about the discouraging outcomes of operating at the lower levels. In many cases, the character is transformed in some way during the course of the story.
Whenever I read such a book to [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
What do you do if you have a problem with a child on the second day of school, before you’ve introduced the Hierarchy levels?
RESPONSE:
Don’t forget that Step One of the Teaching Model is Classroom Management. By proactively teaching specific procedures for everything you want your students to do, you will be able to deal with [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
Dr. Marshall says that we should teach students that in this system of discipline, operation on Levels A and B “automatically invites the use of authority” by the teacher. My students understand that continued operation on the lower levels will result in the use of authority. They see this as a good [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
I remember reading about using a teacher using some trash to introduce the DWS Hierarchy. Where can I find out about this activity? Is it somewhere online?
RESPONSE:
The activity to which you are referring is a description of just one way in which the Discipline without Stress Hierarchy can be introduced to [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


TITLE: Miss Rumphius
AUTHOR: Barbara Cooney
This past spring, I had a very successful lesson with my grade ones and twos using the beautiful and well known picture book, Miss Rumphius. This book is PERFECT for helping students understand what Level D motivation is all about.
Although I had heard of this book before, I had never actually read [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


TITLE:  Hooway for Wodney Wat
AUTHOR:  Helen Lester
This is a great read-aloud, especially if you like taking on different voices!!
Camilla Capybara is a perfect character for introducing the concept of Level B.  Once the kids have correctly identified Camilla’s level of operation, the illustrations really lend themselves to discussing the outcomes and natural consequences of operating [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


QUESTION:
What if a child trips and accidentally hurts another student? Is this Level A behavior according to the RRSystem of discipline?
RESPONSE:
When teaching the Hierarchy, it is important to ensure that students understand that with regard to Level A, we are discussing deliberate actions that result in damage or injury, not accidents. [...]

Click Here for More on this discipline topic...


« Previous PageNext Page »